It’s very common to feel fear and resistance to actively cultivate and solicit individual donors especially if you have never done it before. This can be at both the board and staff level. How do you overcome this so you can grow your organization more sustainably?
What Are You Afraid of?
If you read the previous article Adjusting Your Fundraising Strategy: Don’t Let Grants and Events Rob You of a Sustainable Business Model, it may have dawned on you that you actually prefer the exhaustion and minimal results of events.
Sitting down with another human to talk about how they want to have impact and meaning in their life and how involvement in your organization can help them do it can be quite intimidating.
We may think “What if they say no? What if they feel I’m being pushy, and they never give to us again??? Who am I to have this conversation with them?”
Be honest – what are the voices saying in your head that keep you from doing this?
Recognize the emotions behind this are real, but that the fear is only a story in your head. Research shows again and again donors crave more time with organizational leadership. There is so much money we are leaving on the table for our important causes by not engaging with the people who care about our cause.
How do you have conversations to cultivate and solicit individual donors that don’t feel yucky and salesy?
To both relieve the fear of asking for money and to be more effective at it, ask your donors open-ended questions.
Questions like:
- What made you want to support us?
- What excites you the most about our work?
- If you know they supported another organization in town, ask what motivated that donation (you will learn so much!). Congratulate them on large gifts, even if not to your organization.
Be aware of how much you are talking. Let them do most of the talking, guiding them with questions.
When you do speak, focus on the impact your organization is making now, that is, the lives you’ve helped to change and less on how great you are because you have 5 buildings and 6 programs, or the need for new computers, to repave the parking lot, or give the staff a raise.
Share the impact you could make if you had the financial resources needed. (Of course you need to consider this well before the meeting….)
Share Data (appealing to the donor’s head/logic).
For example, there are 1,500 people on the wait list for a specific service and you are aiming to eliminate it in the next 12 months, or 100% of students graduate from high school who use your services although the graduation rate in the county is 59%.
Share stories (appealing to the heart).
Sally was isolated from her parents and teachers, failing half her classes when we met her. Today she has a 3.5 grade point average and is applying to college.
The discussion of money will come naturally. Be careful not to ask for money in the first conversation. If they have true LIA, (read earlier post to learn what is LIA) make an appointment to see them again, perhaps to come out and visit your facility or program.
Angie, one of my favorite speakers at a recent AFP conference recommends mini-events as part of a cultivation strategy – those with ten people or less. Perhaps a board member hosts a themed dinner at their home where much more meaningful conversations can happen.
Challenge the board and staff to have 100 cups of coffee with donors and potential donors over the next 90 days to determine their LIA.
The sky’s the limit in terms of creativity and getting people into meaningful conversations. 😊
When you know they have LIA and you’ve had the conversation about the impact and investment required to bring this amazing future forward and they have the confidence that your organization is uniquely positioned to do it – they ask them respectfully for a gift. Ask for a specific amount.
Preparation for a Shift in Fundraising Strategy to Actively Cultivate and Solicit Individual Donors
Your team and board need to prepare.
1. Track donor conversations – that is write down the details and the next steps. Very quickly you will not be able to keep them all in your head. And you don’t want to keep them in your head.
Donor cultivation is, at best, a group sport! The heavy lifting is often done by the Development Director and the Executive Director with board members’ strong participation. It’s so important you can share information and have it at your fingertips. There are many software solutions for this, but it can also start with a shared spreadsheet. Here is an example you can download. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dPFTRLbP_pcIV8Szb_pYUF_rN7BGP3Wx/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=100165225729639643073&rtpof=true&sd=true
2. Know your internal data. How many donors do you have now? What has the range and types of gifts been? Which donors might well have LIA and be able to make larger gifts under the right circumstances?
Make a list and start having conversations. Build that muscle. It is great to go with two people to start so you both learn and have another person’s perspective to debrief the meeting. Conversations will become more fruitful and productive as you get #3 and #4 below in place.
3. Develop a shared vision for the future with your board and staff. Can you clearly articulate it? What are you aiming for beyond survival? It does not have to be a full-blown strategic plan.
Start with the desire to eliminate the wait list. What would it cost to do that?
I know of one organization that raised millions of dollars just on that theme.
4. Develop a cultivation and solicitation game plan. Prepare your board with transparent conversations about money, the cost or investment to bring the vision to reality and how they can support this effort. Here’s what to do if members don’t want to ask for money. There are plenty of other ways they can help!
Lastly, have fun with this! Enjoy getting to know your donors better. This is all about unifying behind your important vision and mission. How wonderful that is also a road to a more sustainable business model.
Need help getting started?
Reach out to us, we are happy to help you actively cultivate and solicit individual donors as you build a more sustainable business model.